The Isle of Struay, 10 km off the west coast of Scotland is home to 200 people and enjoys the climate as described in Table 5.1. The island is not connected to the mainland grid and each household independently generates electrical power using a mixture of diesel generators and small scale renewables. Q5 (a) The islanders are investigating their options for electrical generation and connection. The three options for generating and distributing 1000 MWh of electrical energy a year are: ii. Option 2. Install an island grid with renewables, energy storage and ii. Option 3. Install an island grid with a subsea connection to the Table 5.2 shows the costs associated with these three options. Calculate the 40% i. Option 1. No change. back up generation. mainland grid levelised cost of energy of each option. Which option should they go for? (b) If they go for Option 2, the islanders need to use a mixture of renewable energy technologies. Referring to climate data in Table 5.1, your knowledge of renewable energy technologies and similar Scottish island energy schemes, make and explain your recommendation. 30% (c) A retired power engineer who lives on the island suggests that there are other benefits for connecting to the mainland grid. He lists them as security of supply, power system inertia and stability and export of power. Explain what these mean and how a grid connection to the mainland would help. 30% Table 5.1 Monthly climate data for the Isle of Struay Jan--Feb.TMarTApr lay-T Ju n-1Jul|Aug-Sep-TOctー|No.Tec Man Wind Sopecd (os 9.3 8.2-82 7.2 7.2 6.7-162-16.7- 7.7-l s 2-182 18.7- day 1.3 2.3- 3.7一5.8-80-69-58 15.4-4 3-29 11.6-11.2- Mean monthly rainfall (mm) 11381 10111031 73160 165180 107-112 150- 136- 132- Mean Hours of Sunshine per Table 5.2 Costs Options Fixed charge Capital Operation and costs maintenance costs rate 1. No change 2. Install an island grid and renewables, energy storage and backup 3. Install an island grid with connection to the mainland 160,000 ear E1.25m 16,00 0/year 0.1 £2.25m E57,000/year 0.1

The Isle of Struay, 10 km off the west coast of Scotland is home to 200 people and enjoys the climate as described in Table 5.1. The island is not connected to the mainland grid and each household independently generates electrical power using a mixture of diesel generators and small scale renewables. (a) The islanders are investigating their options for electrical generation and connection. The three options for generating and distributing 1000 MWh of electrical energy a year are: i. Option 1. No change. ii. Option 2. Install an island grid with renewables, energy storage and back up generation. iii. Option 3. Install an island grid with a subsea connection to the mainland grid. Table 5.2 shows the costs associated with these three options. Calculate the levelised cost of energy of each option. Which option should they go for? (b) If they go for Option 2, the islanders need to use a mixture of renewable energy technologies. Referring to climate data in Table 5.1, your knowledge of renewable energy technologies and similar Scottish island energy schemes, make and explain your recommendation. (c) A retired power engineer who lives on the island suggests that there are other benefits for connecting to the mainland grid. He lists them as “security of supply”, “power system inertia and stability” and “export of power”. Explain what these mean and how a grid connection to the mainland would help.

Expert Answer

 

A critical piece of information is ambiguous, so both the cases have been calculated.

I hope it is Helpful 🙂

Case 1 ( assuming that maintenance costs are on per house basis )
costs number of total
capital maintenance households maintenance fixed units fixed*units*households total
0 160000 200 32000000 0 1000 0 32000000
1250000 16000 200 3200000 0.1 1000 20000 4470000 minimum
2250000 57000 200 11400000 0.1 1000 20000 13670000
Case 2 ( assuming that maintenance costs are fixed for the whole island )
costs
options capital maintenance fixed units households fixed*units*households total
no change 0 160000 0 1000 200 0 160000 minimum
install an energy grid & backup 1250000 16000 0.1 1000 200 20000 1286000
install an energy grid with connection to mainland 2250000 57000 0.1 1000 200 20000 2327000